A sump pump that never shuts off is usually stuck on — a jammed float switch, a failed check valve letting water flow back into the pit, or a pump too small for the water coming in. A constantly running pump burns out its motor months or years early, and a burned-out pump fails exactly when you need it: during the next big rain. If yours hasn't cycled off in hours, it needs attention before the next storm, not after.
Is This an Emergency?
A pump running constantly during dry weather is urgent-but-bookable — the motor is wearing itself out, but the basement is dry for now. It becomes an emergency when the pump can't keep up and water is rising in the pit, when the pump goes quiet unexpectedly (it may have burned out), or when heavy rain is forecast within 48 hours and your only pump is misbehaving. Toronto's storm season doesn't wait for convenient timing.
The 3 Most Common Causes
Stuck float switch
The float switch is the bobber that rises with the water and tells the pump to run — and it's the number-one failure point. It gets wedged against the pit wall, tangled in the power cord, or gummed up with silt, and then it never drops back down to signal "off." The pump runs forever, doing nothing, cooking its own motor. This is the best-case cause and the most common one we find.
Failed check valve
The check valve sits on the discharge pipe and stops pumped water from flowing back down into the pit when the pump cycles off. When it fails — the flapper wears out or debris holds it open — every gallon the pump pushes up slides right back down, the float never drops, and the pump runs in an endless loop pumping the same water. You'll hear it cycling water without the pit level ever really falling.
Undersized pump
Sometimes the pump is working exactly as designed — it's just too small for the job. A high water table, poor exterior grading directing water at the foundation, or a pit that collects from a large area can overwhelm a light-duty pump. It runs constantly because the inflow genuinely matches its output. That's not a malfunction; it's a sizing problem, and the fix is a bigger pump, not a repair.
What to Try Before You Call Us
One honest test: lift the float switch by hand, then let it drop. If the pump shuts off when you lower it, the switch is sticking — try clearing debris and making sure it moves freely without touching the pit wall or cords. If it still won't shut off, or the switch moves freely and the pump runs anyway, stop — that's a check valve or sizing issue, and it needs a pro's eyes.
What NOT to Do
Don't unplug the pump "to give it a rest" and forget about it — an unplugged sump pump during rain season is how basements flood. Don't keep running a pump that's clearly struggling without investigating; a burned-out motor always picks the worst possible moment. And don't replace the pump with a bigger one yourself without checking the discharge line and check valve — an oversized pump on a bad check valve just fails louder.
When the Pump Can't Keep Up
Water rising in the pit while the pump runs full tilt means inflow is beating the pump — that's beyond switches and valves. It might be an undersized pump, a blocked discharge line (frozen or clogged outside), or groundwater volume no residential pump was sized for. Don't wait for the water to find the floor: this is the call-before-the-storm situation, and we'd rather size you correctly now than pump out your basement later.
How We Fix It
We diagnose the whole setup — float switch, check valve, discharge line, pump sizing against your pit and water table — and fix what's actually wrong instead of just swapping parts. $100 diagnosis, and you approve the repair price before any work begins. If the pump is undersized or aging out, we'll price a proper replacement honestly. And here's the part most homeowners don't know: Toronto's basement flooding subsidy covers sump pump installations — $2,250 toward the pump setup plus $300 for a battery backup, so you're protected even in a power outage. See our basement flooding rebates guide for the full program. One-year warranty on all repairs and installs.
Call (289) 233-7221 · (289) 233-7221
Questions We Hear About This
How long should a sump pump last?
Typically 7–10 years with normal cycling. A pump that runs constantly can burn out in a fraction of that — which is why "runs all the time" is worth fixing promptly rather than treating as a quirk. If yours is past eight years and acting up, replacement usually beats repair.
Do I really need a battery backup?
Ask anyone who's watched their basement fill during a power outage in a storm — which is exactly when pumps are needed most. The battery backup keeps the pump running when the grid doesn't. And the city agrees with us: the subsidy covers $300 of it.
Why does the pump run even when it's not raining?
Groundwater doesn't follow the weather report — a high water table feeds the pit steadily, and spring thaw saturates the ground for weeks after the snow's gone. Constant dry-weather running still usually traces back to the float switch or check valve rather than the water itself. The lift-the-float test sorts it out.
How fast can you get here?
We dispatch 24/7 across Toronto and the GTA. A pump that's losing ground to rising water, or a dead pump with rain in the forecast, is treated as urgent — call now.
Related: Why Is My Basement Floor Drain Backing Up? · Sewer Backup in the Basement · Basement Flooding Rebates